GNOME weighs a generative AI moderation policy
Emmanuele Bassi's RFC aims to end plausible deniability on machine-written contributions, and the proposal has split the project.
GNOME is considering a project-wide moderation policy on generative artificial intelligence, written by Emmanuele Bassi as a rule for how people collaborate rather than a mandate on tools or technical choices.
Bassi wrote that the RFC is not meant to catch violations. "The goal is to remove plausible deniability, and to force a choice between following the policy and intentionally violating it." He also shut down calls for a poll of Foundation members, saying the process is a discussion, not a popularity contest.
The proposal landed in a project already split on machine-written code. Longtime contributor Ray Strode (halfline) argued that any policy should stick to points he called non-controversial: the contributor is responsible, not the tool; no flood of submissions; and no patches that merely smell of a model. He read the draft as going further, banning work by provenance rather than by the quality of the result, and said a contribution that began in a language model could not then be "reworked" into compliance. Bassi has said that someone who understands the policy can be told to revise an assisted contribution until it no longer violates it, and that individual projects can still decide how strictly to treat that smell.
Others reject that framing. Contributors argued that allowing the tools is itself controversial, citing environmental cost and the conduct of the companies that build them, and that GNOME still has a choice not to depend on them. Sebastian Stendahl (sstendahl) called the net effect of large language models on software disastrous, but warned that judging technology by who invented it opens a can of worms the project cannot consistently apply. Christian Schaller (uraeus) called parts of the agency argument toxic and a fast way to shrink the community.
Strode said reading the draft left him feeling disenfranchised after contributing since 1999. Michael Downey replied that no proposal forces anyone to participate in GNOME.